Favorite quote and a plane crash
December 7th, 2008 by Greg
I am banging this out just to pass on some quick info to someone so you’ll forgive the lack of proofreading. You know who you are. This post will self-destruct in the near future.
After giving it some serious thought, my favorite quote would be a lyric, if that is allowed.
It is from Time by Pink Floyd and the lyric is:
And you run and you run to catch up with the sun, but its sinking And racing around to come up behind you again The sun is the same in the relative way, but you're older Shorter of breath and one day closer to death
It sounds a little fatalistic or morose, but for me it really sums up the larger message of the song. The complete lyrics, by the way are:
Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day You fritter and waste the hours in an off hand way Kicking around on a piece of ground in your home town Waiting for someone or something to show you the way Tired of lying in the sunshine staying home to watch the rain You are young and life is long and there is time to kill today And then one day you find ten years have got behind you No one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun And you run and you run to catch up with the sun, but its sinking And racing around to come up behind you again The sun is the same in the relative way, but youre older Shorter of breath and one day closer to death Every year is getting shorter, never seem to find the time Plans that either come to naught or half a page of scribbled lines Hanging on in quiet desperation is the english way The time is gone, the song is over, thought Id something more to say
He is really talking about the same thing I was in my very first post: You look away for a moment and ten years have slipped past. You can’t wait on someone to tell you to start living. The specific lyric I like paints a picture for me of the daily chase of going to work, racing home, little time left before time to go to sleep, only to do it again the next day; in other words, a rut. In that existence, before you know it you’re at the end of your time here and have nothing to show for it. I don’t mean physical things, I mean emotional ones. Something that will let you die fulfilled, not wanting. I’m not planning my big exit anytime soon mind you but, like retirement, if you don’t plan now there won’t be a later.
So, for me, the song is a motivational one. It reminds me that life can be short and I have to make my own future. Noone is going to do it for me.
Now, on to plane crashes… A little back history first: I’ve been flying light airplanes as a hobby for a number of years now. I am a predictably by the book pilot and consider myself a safe one because of it. I fly the numbers, as they say. I don’t push the envelope unless I have to because the cost of falling outside the envelope is, well, often the highest cost there is.
In aviation there is a longstanding tradition of the “$100 hamburger” It is basically something you do when you just want to go out and fly but don’t have any reason to. You fly to another small airport and grab a burger at the airport restaurant. Airport restaurants usually have *really* good burgers, by the way. The joke is that you pay $10 for the burger and $90 to get there, hence the $100 hamburger. Well, on a nice April day 6 years ago I decided I wanted a $100 hamburger.
My home airport is Briscoe Field/Gwinnett county Airport (LZU) mainly because it is very convenient to where I live. 10 to 15 minutes depending on traffic. I was going to go up there and fly down to Peachtree DeKalb Airport (PDK) which is only about 30 minutes from my house in the opposite direction. Rachel wanted to go along with me. I should add that her mother, who is deathly afraid of little planes, really didn’t want her to go but acquiesced after my barrage of safety stats on aviation showing how safe it was. She still didn’t like it.
My original plan was to rent a Cessna 172 for the flight. I was and am still good friends with Matt, the guy who taught me to fly, so I called him up and asked if he’d like to come along. In the time since Matt instructed me he’d gone on to become the chief pilot of a small charter operation that operated out of LZU. He agreed and suggested I take their Piper Aztec, which is a 6 seat twin engine craft. You see, small airplanes are all air cooled and their engines run at near maximum output the majority of the time they are running. As a result, they can be a little finicky. I mean, if you get it running it rarely quits, but if you leave them sitting unused too long they tend to give you problems starting. Gremlins love an idle plane. Since the charter operation had a Queen Air which is a cabin class aircraft and the Aztec, the Aztec almost never got used. It was really more of an emergency backup in case the Queen Air was out of commission unexpectedly or they had a scheduling conflict. Since the Aztec hadn’t been flown in almost two weeks it really needed to be used. So Matt suggested I take it on a ‘stir flight’ instead of renting a plane. Basically, it just needed to be flown.
Delighted at the turn of events because (a) My burger cost just dropped back down to $10 and (b) multi-engine time is hard to come by as a recreational pilot, I accepted his offer. Rachel and I went to the airport a short time later, pre-flighted and off we went. Since PDK is very close and the Aztec is pretty fast we were there in no time.
An important tangent here is that I hate flying into PDK. It is the second busiest airport in the state, behind only Atlanta Hartsfield International (which holds the record as the busiest airport in the world), but some of their controllers are inept in my experience. This isn’t unfounded either. They’ve given me bad instructions a couple of times before, the worst of which was clearing me to land on a runway that they’d already cleared a Hawker jet to land on. I turned final while the jet was still out of sight but it didn’t take him long to catch me. My approach speed in a Cessna is around 65MPH, his is closer to 200. Luckily he saw me and aborted his landing. He passed so close over me that I could hear his engines over my own and could have done a fairly thorough inspection of his aircraft if I coulda kept up. In other words, they came close to killing both me and those in the Hawker.
One other important note is that the Cessna is a fixed gear aircraft, meaning the wheels are always down, they don’t retract. The Aztec, on the other hand, has retractable gear.
So, anyhow, we call into PDK tower and get landing clearance to runway 20L, also known as their “long runway”. Unfortunately, in their ineptness, they’d cleared us in too close behind a much slower airplane. They only noticed this when we were a touch over a quarter mile out. Considering my approach speed was in excess of 100MPH, that isn’t very far. I’d dutifully done my pre-landing check list earlier which included, among other things, pulling back power, rolling out flaps and dropping the landing gear which includes checking for “three good green” lights that show they are down and locked.
Well, when the dummies in the tower realized their mistake they quickly told me to give them a ‘right 360 for spacing’. In other words, fly a big circle off to your right to give the other guy time to get off the runway. The problem with that is that I’m already at almost treetop level and I am set up for descent. That means that I have power pulled back to nearly idle, and the plane is flying dirty (an aviation term for wheels out, flaps out which increase drag which slows you and makes the plane aerodynamically ‘dirty’) which makes even leveling out and holding altitude impossible, much less turning. So I had no choice but to retract gear and flaps as I shoved both engines to full power to arrest my descent. I flew the 360 they requested but now came out at 1/4 mile from the threshold with no landing prep done. In retrospect, I should have called no-joy and gone around, but hindsight is always 20-20, isn’t it?
So as I leveled out from the turn I did a VERY rushed pre-landing checklist. Basically power back, wheels down, full flaps and carb heat on. I heard the gear cycle out so I moved on and didn’t wait for the 3 good green; I didn’t have time to anyhow. That should have been my first clue this landing was dumb. You should always have time to check those lights if you do nothing else.
I am crossing the threshold as I complete the rushed checklist list from memory and I settle in to land. Takeoffs and landings are statistically the most dangerous times in any flight by far even under ideal circumstances. Under mine, it was ridiculous. I bled off speed and began to flare and ease onto the ground. Since the Aztec is a low wing plane (wings are under you, not over you like in a Cessna) the tips of the props are not much more than a foot off the ground once you land. Well, I’m doing 100MPH over a very large expanse of featureless concrete so depth perception can be tricky.
At about the time I though ‘Wow! I must’ve really greased that one on. Didn’t even feel the wheels touch’ I heard the first prop tip strike the concrete. I knew immediately what it was and went into oh-*#&% mode. Once you have a prop strike, there is no way to get back of the ground. You are committed. I shifted my concentration then to keeping the plane on the runway center-line since, getting off in the grass gives the plane things to dig into and start flipping. Not good. As various parts of the plane came into contact with the ground it yawed wildly from side to side. My only defense was the huge rudder on the Aztec so I pushed those peddles like my life depended on it, because it might. While we are sliding down the runway (we went close to 2000 feet and it felt like it took about 45 minutes!) Rachel (13 at the time) was going “daddy, is this normal?” to which I gave the universal not now hand signal.
As soon as we came to a halt I grabbed Rachel and almost threw her out the door (which was on the right side of the fuselage) and rushed out behind her. I grabbed her and ran several hundred feet since all the fuel is stored in the wings that I’d just drug for 2000 feet or so. And since we’d had a very short flight they probably still held around 130 gallons of quite flammable avgas. I don’t need to describe what would happen if it ignited. It didn’t. Fortunately the fuel cells held and we had not so much as a drop leak.
That few moments (as well as the next couple of hours too, I guess) was surreal. I stood on the grass beside the runway looking at my airplane sitting on the ground, the last 8 or 10 inches of each prop blade bent straight back. There was complete silence for a few moments before hearing the distant drone of the fire gear being rolled out. Moments later there were two large airport firetrucks bracketing my plane and people were asking lots of questions.
It was 4 hours before the plane could be moved because the FAA and NTSB had to send investigators out before anyone could mess with it. And it was Friday afternoon. And I’d just shut down the long runway for the rest of the afternoon. And the long runway is the only one long enough for most of the business jets there to take off from. And it is the second busiest airport in the state. Yeah, I made a few people mad.
There is an old saying in aviation: “Any landing you can walk away from is a good landing. Any landing where you can use the plane again is a great landing.” While I did manage to honor the other big pilot’s adage “shiny side up, dirty side down” I failed miserable on the “great landing” test. The airplane never flew again.
I called a flying buddy of mine while I was standing out there waiting and it went like “Hey, what’s up?”, “Oh, I’m down at PDK”, “Oh? grabbing a burger?”, “Weeeelll. That was the plan anyhow”, “huh?”, “Well, I just had my first landing that was good, but not great.”, “?!?!?!?!”
While standing there I looked up and saw the channel 46 news chopper hovering a mile or so out with their cameras trained on us. Great. Last thing I need is for Rachel’s mom to see us on the news over the heading ‘Plane crashes at PDK’. I dreaded that call, but I made it.
Second only to that call was the one for the ride home. We called the owner of the airplane (who I’d never met) and he headed over to pick us up. I wasn’t looking forward to that. At that point I could only assume I’d forgotten to deploy landing gear in the rushed pre-landing setup and had just effectively totaled a couple hundred thousand dollars worth of airplane. And the owner of said plane was coming to pick me up. Hmmm.
He arrived and ran out to where we were, which was illegal. The runway he crossed on foot to get out there was an active, in use one and the tower was far less than amused. I don’t think I had them in a good mood to begin with. Again, oops. Well, the owner was gracious and more concerned for our well being. I thought “Man, what a magnanimous guy”. At least until we got to his car. There he turned almost jubilant. Yeah, that’s right, he was happy. Turns out he’d been trying to sell the Aztec for close to eight months and I’d just effectively sold it to the insurance company for him. Never know what life is gonna throw your way, huh? Walking out through the flight ops center full of people gawking at my plane as it was hauled in on a 4 wheel dolly, all of them assuming it was my mad skillz that put it there, was a bit of a walk of shame, but nothing I could do about that.

I was much relieved when the investigation later revealed that I had deployed the landing gear but, due to a hydraulic pressure leak they only came a few inches out. They were still almost horizontal. They did just enough to let me hear the thump and ensuing wind noise to make me think they were down. They wrote it up as an incident rather than an accident which will keep my insurance rates from going up. Yay. I only had to go fly a couple of touch and gos with an FAA inspector in a retrac aircraft to satisfy them that my cockpit management abilities were sufficient. He passed me after the first. Ironically, the only one to get into any trouble with the FAA was the owner of the airplane for his running into a controlled movement space without clearance. Go figure.
I guess I can mark plane crash off my to-do list. I later tried to tell Rachel’s mom that now she was really safe flying with me because, statistically speaking, the odds of that happening twice were almost nil. I am the safest guy in the world to fly with now. She wasn’t buying. I flew Rachel anyhow. Just how life is sometimes, right? I’ll say this much; at least it was a memorable day.
/g
Category: Uncategorized | No Comments »




